Received as a gift for xmas and have been using sporadically since then. Loved these eye liners at first but then the tips kept breaking off, wasting product. They do go smoothly and pigment is good but they don't stay in place if you have allergies or cry. Then they ran out completely so that's that. Not a lot of product in each - mmmmaaaaybe an inch and a half. Will replace w drugstore brand Jordana that goes on creamy, doesn't budge & is a fraction of the price.