I think this product is fine, but there are better ones out there. First of all, it does not seem to be waterproof. Lots of running under the eye. Maybe it is that way because it is a smudge stick, but is was really too messy. Also, it is not as creamy as some liners, and the product does not roll up easily. I also thought the plastic applicator part of the product seemed cheap. And the bracelet it comes with is cheesy, but my 4 year old daughter thought it was fun dress up jewelry.
Not the best eyeliner
The eyeliner goes on my fine, but towards the end of the day I notice smuges on my eye lid.
This is a great price for all 3 liners plus you get the cute bracelet and the gift card which makes it a steal! The liner goes on smoothly and the colors are intense. The liner is a gel formula which makes it easy to smudge with a brush right after application to get the perfect smokey eye. The liner lasts all day and doesn't budge but easily comes off with wipes or eye makeup remover.
I so wish I had read reviews on other sites before buying this. It simply does not twist up to dispense more product! You could literally spend your entire day twisting it and no more product would ever come out. I found many other people who agree with me. I went searching to see if I was dong it wrong! Make sure you read up on this product and I would not recommend buying it. The bracelet was the only good part.
Great all around products
First, let me say that I love the bonus bracelet. It's super fun & sparkly and the hearts are a nice touch. As for the smudge sticks...PERFECT for the woman on the run. I wore one for a day out and 12 hours later, I still looked good (minus a bit of face powder and blush) but the eye liner stood up beautifully. I also love the colors!