Not so sure about the cult following of tho pencil.
I know this pencil has a huge following but I am kind of underwhelmed. It smudges and slides and creases and generally leaves me looking like a hot mess an hour after I have applied it. I do like the sponge smudger on the end however.
If you ever buy one of these it won't be the last time you do. This is the nicest eye pencil I have ever used. The built in blender is awesome.
Works as a liner as well as an eyeshadow. The smudge tip makes application a breeze. Hard to find a good green, but the khaki worked well.
OK, but not the best
I liked that the pencil came with a smudge tip, but I think (for me) the pencil point was way too broad even with using the smudge tip.
Creamy texture and easy application
Love the creaminess, goes on smoothly and very easy to "smudge" to create an easy "day-time smokey" eye look. Big fan, I have the light grey color, which is super versatile. Would be interested in trying other colors - wish they carry more color variations!
Great texture and very rich color. Goes on super easy and a little goes a long way. Substitute your eyeshadow with this liner by smudging.
What was I thinking? This color was not what I expected. Washed out look for me. And way too fat a line.
really nice liner
I ordered the purple "ava" color and it's lovely. Soft smoky purple, goes great with hazel or green eyes. The pencil is on the chubby side, good for a smudgy look.
Great all-purpose eye product
A great tool for quick eye makeup application (think mornings when you overslept and have, like, 5 minutes to fix your face). The liner is creamy and goes on even, and I love having the blender at the end to tone things down or fix botches. I ordered the Ava, which is an amethyst color, and it's a nice medium purple which complements my green eyes. I will definitely purchase more of these in the future. Only drawback is I do need to reapply by the end of the day, because the color fades.
bold color that lasts
I love this eye intensifier pencil. I can get a strong line that makes my eyes pop, and can smudge for a smokier look. Plus, I can put it on at stoplights when I'm late for work! I always have at least one of these sticks in my bag.