It's only December and my lips are already taking a beating from the cold so I decided to give these balms a try. All four smell very nice and go on smooth. The color is very faint because I didn't notice any color on my lips. But these balms don't work for me as balm is too thin in consistency and didn't moisturize my lips at all. Also, don't put these in your pocket, as they melt with the slightest bit of body heat.