I got this eyeliner in a shimmery forest green and I love it! It adds just a pop of color to my eyes without being ostentatious or too fancy for everyday wear. My only complaint was that after I wore down the tip, I couldn't figure out how to sharpen it. I had to buy a new, sharper pencil sharpener to cut through to more eyeliner. But once I went through all that effort I was glad to have more!