I have to give this product mixed reviews. I like the ease of the actual application and bold, vibrate colors. However, it is next to impossible to sharpen because the inside is very soft and breaks very easily. I found out that even though it comes with a sharpener, it does not sharpen well. I love the colors and the smoothness, but I was not able to use it because of the inconsistency of the the product. I found this happened with all of the pencils that I bought. I think you should try it for yourself and I hope you have more luck and a more positive experience.
I absolutely love this rose gold shade; I wear it quite often; it can be a subtle glint with a light application & the smudger. If you want a more intense color - apply with more pressure.
I do find it is very soft and does tend to break so I use an artist's palette when it crumbles and then I apply with a small eye shadow brush. Works like a charm and doesn't waste that precious color.
I ordered the purple shade and it is amazingly pretty. Not like so many liners that look kind of like a bruise. This stuff stays put, no smearing whatsoever and has a nice basic no-gell-y feeling. The best eyeliner I've bought in years.
This eyeliner was hard to sharpen, the tip of kept breaking off. The tip kept breaking off even when applying to my eyes. The sharpener cap would not stay on and kept coming off in my makeup back making a mess. I would pass on this product.
I got the pink color and love it. The pencil tip is not hard and is soft enough to make a thin or fatter line depending on your mood. The color is not in your face. The pencil glides on without having to dig into your skin to get the color on.