I decided to try this cleanser mainly to remove my eye makeup and mascara, but also because I was using a thick BB cream that was not easily removed by my cleansers. It does a good job, doesn't burn my eyes, doesn't make them blurry, and doesn't require a cotton pad. I do use my fingers to rub it around and really work it into my eyelashes. I like the tubes for travel, but don't know if it's really practical/cost-effective for daily home use. I've resorted to using this pretty much only for my eyes, then using another cleanser for the whole face.
Again, it does work to remove waterproof mascara! I say this because not all oil based cleansers do and most regular cleansers don't.